Disclosure: Friends Over 50 participates in affiliate programs, meaning I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Notes from a casual tasting with friends; thank you to Susan Romano for the photos. 

Shortly after the Christmas holiday, I hosted a small mocktail tasting with friends. I thought it would be a fun excuse to get together, but also I’ve been curious about the options for non-alcoholic cocktails. My instagram feed is flooded with options. I tried a canned mocktail last year, and thought it tasted like dressed-up juice.

For this tasting I thought it would be fun to compare canned mocktails to mocktails made fresh with faux spirits. 

A note for transparency: Drink Monday gifted the non-alcoholic gin and mezcal used in this tasting. I adapted two recipes from their website for this event. Drink Monday had no input on the tasting format, the adaptations, or the conclusions shared here. All opinions are my own.

What surprised me most was how consistently we agreed once we looked past preferences and focused on how the drinks were made. Taster preferences included cocktail drinkers, white wine drinkers, and beer/IPA drinkers. 

The Lineup

We tasted a mix of formats

• Two canned mocktails, including a Peach Mango flavor and a
  rosé-style non-alcoholic aperitif
• Two homemade mocktails using Drink Monday spirits:
  • A Cosmopolitan-style drink made with non-alcoholic gin
  • A Pineapple Mezcal Margarita made with a pineapple syrup

Both homemade drinks were adapted from recipes on Drink Monday’s website and adjusted for how I planned to serve them.

Before we even poured a drink, one thing was immediately clear: people appreciated the presentation. The bottles looked like high-end spirits with clean labeling, substantial glass, and a design that didn’t scream “substitute.” Sitting on my sideboard, they looked intentional and elevated, which set expectations before the first sip.

The Canned Mocktails: Where Things Fell Apart

The canned drinks were the clearest disappointment, and the Peach Mango was the least liked. The feedback was fairly consistent: thin, overly sweet, and somewhat artificial-tasting.

This didn’t feel like a matter of personal preference as much as a limitation of the format. After doing a bit of research, I learned that shelf-stable mocktails are designed to be consistent and long-lasting, which often means relying on dilution and simplified flavor profiles. The tradeoff can be texture and balance. Without enough body or lift, a drink can come across as flat, even when the ingredients sound appealing.

Alcoholic canned cocktails have an advantage that’s easy to overlook: alcohol itself adds weight and structure, helping even simple recipes feel more complete. When alcohol is removed, those same formulas don’t always hold up. Mocktails that work tend to replace that missing structure with body, acidity, or texture. When they don’t, the drink tastes thin, no matter how good the ingredient list looks.

Once poured into glasses, these canned mocktails didn’t really open up or evolve. The results felt driven by the recipe more than personal taste.  

The Rosé Aperitif: Interesting, But Unanchored

The bottled rosé-style aperitif landed somewhere in the middle. No one hated it, but no one loved it either.

It tasted pleasant enough, but more like a flavored beverage than a cocktail alternative. There wasn’t enough acidity or weight to make it feel finished. That’s likely intentional (aperitifs are designed for light sipping) but in a tasting lineup, it felt uncommitted.

This wasn’t a failure so much as a category mismatch. It didn’t convincingly replace a cocktail, and it didn’t fully stand on its own.

The Cosmo Mocktail: When One Choice Changes Everything

This was the most instructive drink of the night.

First, context matters: gin is polarizing. Several tasters simply don’t like gin, regardless of whether it contains alcohol. That preference shaped their reaction to the Drink Monday non-alcoholic gin.

But there was a second, more important issue.

Because I wasn’t serving this drink over ice, I followed the adapted recipe and added water for dilution. The result was a drink that felt watered down and flat. Everyone agreed it lacked presence.

Later that evening, after everyone left, I made the same drink for myself as a single serve, no added water, just shaken and strained. It was noticeably better. Still gin-forward, still not for everyone, but far more balanced.

The lesson was clear: many mocktail recipes are written to be shaken with ice. Replacing that with added water requires adjustment. In this case, the added water flattened the drink instead of opening it up. This wasn’t about the spirit itself, but about how dilution was handled.

The Clear Winner: Pineapple Mezcal Margarita

The Pineapple Mezcal Margarita was the runaway favorite. The non-alcoholic mezcal from Drink Monday added a smoky depth that didn’t feel like it was compensating for the lack of alcohol. It felt like a real cocktail. That wasn’t accidental.

This recipe worked because it followed basic cocktail principles. The pineapple syrup added body and viscosity, bringing a depth that raw juice doesn’t. The mezcal added a smoky depth that didn’t feel like it was covering up for the lack of alcohol. Unlike the Cosmo, this one wasn’t diluted with added water. It was served over a single large ice cube, which allowed the drink to develop more flavor as the ice melted. The balance of acid, sweet, and texture held on its own, even as the ice melted. Even people unfamiliar with mezcal enjoyed it.

An optional slice of fresh jalapeño added another layer. One taster felt the heat was necessary to balance the sweetness, while another preferred it without. That flexibility turned out to be a strength rather than a flaw.

The spirit didn’t carry the drink alone. The recipe and how it was served gave it structure.

What This Tasting Really Proved

Stepping back, the biggest insight was about design.

What mattered most:

• How a drink feels matters more than how it’s presented
• Dilution must be intentional
• Some flavor profiles read as more “cocktail-like”
• Fresh or cooked ingredients outperform canned shortcuts

Non-alcoholic spirits can’t do all the work. Without a solid recipe underneath, even good products fall flat.

What I’d Do Differently Next Time

If I hosted another tasting, I’d skip most canned mocktails entirely. I’d adjust dilution based on serving method instead of following recipes blindly. And I’d make sure at least one option had real body—syrup, acid, and structure—so it could stand on its own.

Mocktails aren’t about pretending alcohol isn’t missing. When done right, they don’t need to apologize. They just need to be built like cocktails.

My thanks to the friends who came over, tasted with an open mind, and talked through what worked and what didn’t. Their perspectives shaped this post.